The Case Of William Marbury Deserved The Commission Or Not

This case was a case for the ages that challenged the very decision of our newly elected president. The former President Adam after a grueling election has lost and in order to maintain the legacy of the Federalist, he began to appoint justices to the Supreme Court. These judges were appointed by the president and confirmed by the Senate, but unfortunately for these justices, the letters that confirmed the appointment never reached the potential justices. Adams was working quickly to push the appointments through, but unfortunately he ran out of time and Jefferson took office. Jefferson saw the appointment letters on his desk and discarded them. One of the potential justices was William Marbury and he sued the president for his Supreme Court appointment. His goal was to have the court to order a writ of mandamus, which if completed, would order a government official to fulfil their official duties. The Chief justice presented three questions that needed to be decided by the court. The first issue addressed was whether William Marbury deserved the commission or not. The court opened the questioned if the law had a remedy for the situation. The final question was whether the writ of mandamus the appropriate legal action in the case. These questions were debated and the court confirmed that Marbury deserved the commission, but they found that the Judiciary Act of 1789 which allowed the court to submit the very writ of mandamus Marbury needed was unconstitutional. AccordingShow MoreRelatedThe Court Case Of Marbury V. Plessy V Ferguson1119 Words   |  5 Pagesin the court cases of Marbury v Madison, Plessy v Ferguson, and the book To Kill a Mocking Bird by Harper Lee. These cases clearly exemplify that the law does not always provide justice, although it endeavors to do so. In the court case of Marbury v Madison from 1803, it is apparent that justice does not prevail. This case was brought to court because William Marbury was denied his rightful spot to a justice of the peace position in the District of Colombia. This spot and commissions were signedRead MoreThe State Of Public Schools Essay1466 Words   |  6 Pagesjudges and the ability to set district court budgets. Then, the Kansas Governor Sam Brownback, who is in the executive branch, signed a law that would remove the funding of the judicial branch if the Kansas Supreme Court ruled against him in the court case concerning the funding of public schools. The actions of both the legislative and executive branch of Kansas’ government disregard the system of checks and balances because the judicial branch is being punished for doing their job. Therefore, judicialRead MoreThe United States Supreme Court Cases 1946 Words   |  8 PagesStates Supreme Court consists of the Chief Justice of the U nited States and eight associate justices. At its discretion, and within certain guidelines established by Congress, the Supreme Court each year hears a limited number of the cases it is asked to decide. Those cases may begin in the federal or state courts, and they usually involve important questions about the Constitution or federal law. Established by the Constitution within Article III, the Supreme Court was declared the highest federalRead MoreJohn Marshals Life and Work1917 Words   |  8 Pages1777(Newmeyer, 7). While at the Academy Marshall became friends with James Monroe. Thomas Marshall acquired the services of a live-in tutor, James Thompson from Scotland, to educate the Marshall children. Except for a short time spent at the College of William and Mary, this was the sum total Marshalls formal education. With direction from his father, Marshall picked up the rest of his education on his own. Part of Thomas Marshalls influence in his sons education was his introduction to neighbor GeorgeRead MoreJohn Marshall: The Man who Saved the Supreme Court and the Nation2463 Words   |  10 Pages1777(Newmeyer, 7). While at the Academy Marshall became friends with James Monroe. Thomas Marshall acquired the services of a live-in tutor, James Thompson from Scotland, to educate the Marshall children. Except for a short time spent at the College of William and Mary, this was the sum total Marshalls formal education. With direction from his father, Marshall picked up the rest of his education on his own. Part of Thomas Marshalls influence in his sons education was his introduction to neighbor GeorgeRead MoreThe Founding Fathers : Virginia1589 Words   |  7 PagesPurchase†). Marbury vs. Madison was considered one of the most important cases in the history of The Supreme Court. This case was the first to establish the idea of â€Å"judicial review,† the power given to the judicial branch to declare acts of Congress unconstitutional. As his presidency term was ending, Adams appointed multiple justices of peace whose commissions were approved by the Senate and ready to deliver. However, Madison would not deliver them after Jefferson took office in 1801. William Marbury